x

Fifteen Eighty Four

Academic perspectives from Cambridge University Press

Menu
16
Nov
2026

Representing future generations to tackle climate change

Michael Reder, Peter Lawrence

A key motivation for writing ‘Representing future generations: climate change and the global legal order’ was that arguments drawn from philosophy, law and international relations could be combined in fruitful ways to feed into climate litigation and justify and evaluate proposals to represent future generations at the global level. Our book addresses the question of why we should represent future generations in the global legal order, before going on to consider what form which such representation should take, examined through case studies.

A distinctive feature of the book is its methodology based on John Dewey’s philosophical pragmatism which involves a bottom-up approach where one examines values embodied in existing discourses and institutions and rules and then see how these can be extended to cope with a new problem. We argue that the concepts of solidarity, intergenerational justice and vulnerability are already embedded in existing international legal discourses and can be extended and used as a basis to justify institutions to represent future generations.

However, intergenerational justice (fairness between those alive now and those born in the future) cannot be considered in isolation from fairness between people alive now – intragenerational justice and fairness between countries (international justice).  Indeed, in examining some existing mechanisms in the UN which indirectly provide representation to particularly vulnerable groups (women, children and disabled people) we observed that a development discourse grounded in international justice was crucial in the establishment of each mechanism. Similarly, any global mechanisms to represent future generations, such as the proposed UN special envoy for future generations (one of the case studies of the book), which is currently on hold owing to UN budget cuts, to be successful will need to demonstrate how it addresses developing country concerns to gain legitimacy and support.

Representation of nonhuman nature, upon which future generations of human beings depend, is also of vital importance but not covered by our volume.

There is currently a serious bias against the interests of future generations in international law-making and institutions in the sense that their interests are marginalised. Thus scientists point out that even if fully implemented, the Paris climate agreement commitments will take us well over the global average temperature increase considered safe by scientists (UNEP Emissions Gap Report 2025).

One important reason for this bias is that future generations don’t have a voice. Proxy style mechanisms which represent future generations can help overcome this. Such mechanisms do not constitute a silver bullet for solving the climate crisis; mainstreaming future generations’ interests in lawmaking is essential. Nevertheless, proxy style mechanisms should be urgently developed as a parallel strategy.

Bias implies a fairness benchmark. Our approach rests on the claim that international law whatever other purposes it has, ought to further justice, extended to include intergenerational justice. In addressing the law, we use a version of Legal Realism which means when application of the traditional sources of international law do not yield a clear result, one then should turn to the underlying normative basis of the whole system – the promotion of justice – extended to include intergenerational justice.

We argue that intergenerational justice involves ensuring that all persons regardless of when or where they are born are able to enjoy the human rights necessary to lead a decent life.  This means that at the very least, all states meet the minimum essential level required of all human rights set out in the UN human rights covenants. While the idea that a person not yet born can possess human rights has proven contentious, we point out that the view has gained acceptance that human beings born in the future are potentially legal subjects, acquiring the status upon birth, and this is sufficient to justify our responsibility towards future generations.

Such proxy style mechanisms to represent future generations can be justified by application of the ideal of democracy at international level. This is contentious given that many states are undemocratic. But the democratic ideal enjoys at least formal support in a number of UN instruments. Moreover it applies at the international level for the same reason it does at the national level – it increases the likelihood that decisions reflect the will of the people, it reduces the risk of abuse of power and furthers the likelihood of just outcomes.

While theories of democracy tend to have a blind spot in relation to future generations and were not devised with the global ecological crisis in mind (see also Michael Reder and Simon Faets (2024)), they nevertheless, tend to embody the so-called ‘all affected principle’ according to which those affected by a decision should have a say in the making of that decision. The only way future generations can have a say in decisions being made now which affect them is through some type of proxy representation.

Proxy representation, put simply, involves representation of the voiceless. Inspired by international relations theory we develop a theory of proxy representation in the international legal order which breaks down such representation in accordance with its functions, whether these be: representational (purporting to speak on behalf of future generations, compliance (ensuring compliance with a rule which furthers the interests of future generations), norm entrepreneurial (promoting a rule which promotes the interests of future generations such as intergenerational equity), or law reform. Using these categories provides a more nuanced understanding of the functions and effectiveness of mechanisms to represent future generations.

Thus the proposed UN special envoy for future generations, would be most likely to be effective if it maximised all the proxy representation functions mentioned above. This would involve it promoting the norm of ‘intergenerational equity’ as well as a range of law reform functions across the UN system to ensure better incorporation of the interests of future generations. 

A case study in the book on the 2025 International Court of Justice (ICJ) advisory opinion on climate change (written before it came out) puts the argument that the court ought to have fleshed out the concept of intergenerational equity in various ways. The ICJ ‘s advisory opinion was a strong decision in terms of furthering intergenerational justice in many respects. And the Court did specify that intergenerational equity required states to take ‘due regard’ to the interests of future generations in implementing climate-related international law obligations. However, arguably the court could have gone further in indirectly representing future generations and fleshing out in more detail what is required of states to meet the requirements of intergenerational equity (see Lawrence 2026).

In conclusion, our hope is that ‘Representing Future generations’ contributes to developing proxy style mechanisms to represent future generations at the international level. Future generations deserve nothing less.

Representing Future Generations

Climate Change and the Global Legal Order | 9781009655859

.

Latest Comments

Have your say!